Classroom Formative Assessment

“Improved formative assessment helps low achievers more than other students and so reduces the range of achievement while raising achievement overall”

How “good” is good enough.

February 26th, 2009 by · No Comments · classroom formative assessment

As I find myself making fabulous mistakes and improving my teaching, finding more and more effective ways to help my students become better learners I am struck by this notion of; How “good” is good enough. I have reached the summit with selecting targets and clarifying them for my students. I feel confident in my rubrics and exemplars and other tools that help my students define proficient for their work and for their understanding….or do I?  The discussions regarding the 90-90-90 schools keeps me thinking, would any teacher be able to walk into my room…use the tools I’ve supplied my students as a guide for grades and grade my kids the same way I would? Well, I’ve put it to the first of what I imagine will be many tests. 

I used the opportunity created by attending this group to enlist a sub to help me test just this. In my sub plans I asked my sub (who, by the way, was the fabulous and amazing retired Kindergarten teacher Mrs. Judi Martinez…so we all know she knows her “stuff”. ) to use my exemplars as tools and grade an assignment that she gave the students while I was away. I did not ask her to take into account anyone’s ELL status, nothing about the higher or lower ability levels in the room. She was to use the descriptors and exemplars of proficient work to grade my students on their performance. 

I must say I was very pleasantly surprised that in all but one case the sub and I agreed completely on what proficient looked like and because it was based on more than a subjective feeling of “good” work and because it was clearly outlined inside my classroom this was possible. 

I then took it one step farther….I conferences with my students individually and asked them why they think they received the mark they did on that assignment. Again success! Most (yes there were about 4 of 42 that cocked their  5 year old heads to one side and gave me a blank look. ) could verbalize exactly what proficient was to look like and how their work contained those qualities. 

So now I come to the point of my post…..finally!

I  would like to extend and continue this little experiment and I ask for your  help. I’m looking for some ambitious soul to grade some of my students works based on the tools we use in the classroom to describe proficient and in return I’ll happily do the same. Let’s work together. The commitment involved to grade my assignment is about an hour. 

 

Any takers? 

 

Beginning after conferences is absolutely the plan. 

 

Angelina Harskjold

Thimmig Kindergarten

aharskjold@sd27j.org

Tags:

Days of thinking…

February 17th, 2009 by · No Comments · classroom formative assessment

I really appreciate these days of learning.  Having everyone in one room helps share the message.   We are better able to begin speaking the same language.  The questions and conversations that I have had the pleasure of participating in, are so helpful and just make me think and think and think. 

Next training coming up…

February 12th, 2009 by · No Comments · classroom formative assessment

I’m sending the parking lot from the last day of training by email, and here are the questions/comments I want to talk about at this stage of the game.

  1. There are lots of questions that will be addressed in the next three days.  I am thinking particularly of questions like
    1. I want to know how to teach metacognition
    2. More strategies on how to make kids learners
    3. How to engage students to become better thinkers of their thinking
    4. How do we clearly define what objectives and targets are?
    5. I want more strategies
  2. Grading and report cards.  I have very deliberately avoided dealing with changing report cards until we have changed the way we grade, and we can’t change the way we grade until teachers have acquired a practice that will replace the current function of grades.  It is no accident that the chapter about report cards in Classroom Assessment for Student Learning is one of the last chapters in the book.  Let’s have this discussion when we’ve completed the training.  There are lots of resources out there now that we can use to move us forward.  I believe we are starting in the right place.
  3. If this is so important, will all teachers receive this training?  The simple answer to that is yes, but I don’t know yet how it will happen.  It feels like a big move forward to me that we are doing this training, and at the same time I don’t want to do anything that implies that once we are done with these four days, there’s nothing else to do.  Therefore, this will have to be an ongoing discussion with principals and their leadership teams, because almost all work of implementation will be done at the building level.  And the truth is, all schools ARE embarked on this work in one way or another.  Some are explicitly studying CASL, others are working on clarity of target, but all principals have been very involved in discussion about how to move their buildings forward.  It just isn’t always explicit how their current professional development plan connects with classroom formative assessment, and I hope that principals will take the opportunity to discuss with the teachers whom they have brought to the training about whether it should be more explicit or whether that would muddy the waters at their schools.  It’s a great question about clarity of target…
  4. What is the connection between this training and the instructional model?  I addressed that question directly on my blog: click here.  My blog is FULL of thoughts about formative assessment, so PLEASE take the time to look through it sometime.  The link to the blog itself is http://isobelstevenson.edublogs.org/
  5. How do I motivate unmotivated students?  I have SO MUCH to say about this, so I’m working on a separate post.  Again, there are lots of good resources out there about this, so please let me know if you want specific questions answered or want to talk about it more.

I am very excited about the next day of training coming up!

A Short Tutorial on How to Post

January 27th, 2009 by · No Comments · Blogging Tips

If you’ve never blogged before, you’ll be pleasantly surprised at how easy it is to post to the “Classroom Formative Assessment Blog.”  I created this short tutorial for you that demonstrates how to post to the blog and help us keep this community as organized as possible.  Just click the link below:

Posting to the CFA Blog (I’ve uploaded new media – heard the original wasn’t working correctly – sorry!)

Posting to the CFA Blog (Windows Media Player)

Posting to the CFA Blog (Quicktime)

What I’d like to do is start posting some “Blogging Tips” for us all so that we can maintain a community where we can all post, but also utilize each other’s thoughts, ideas and strategies for utilizing what we’re learning from the Classroom Formative Assessment training.  Since we have over 100 authors on this blog, I’m hoping we can try to keep it as organized as possible through the use of “tags” (keywords that make an entry searchable) and categories (assigning blog entries to specific categories to make searching much easier – bear in mind that one entry may be applicable in multiple categories – you can choose multiple, if it suits).  I created the mini-module above to simply take you through the process of logging in, writing a post, making it searchable and viewing the product of your hard work.  I did place the video on TeacherTube for easy embedding, but you may have trouble streaming it on a district computer – the link below should work.

So, be on the lookout for some thoughts from me on utilizing this blog – feel free to add some yourself – just be sure to categorize them as “Blogging Tips,” making them much easier to find.  And so – we blog!

Tags: ···

Ready!

January 27th, 2009 by · No Comments · classroom formative assessment

Ian has added all the attendees at the first day of training, so we are all set.  So I am hoping there are very few glitches left and that teachers will start writing about their experience with classroom formative assessment.

I met with my team yesterday, and it’s clear from hearing their reports of table discussions that different schools are in different places, and we really want to support teachers wherever they are.

I’m really looking forward to reading what experiences people have in trying to implement this practice, and I’m going to ask that teachers who’ve had previous exposure to this training and the implementation start writing about what they’ve done… You know who you are.

Almost ready to roll!! A learning network in the making . . .

January 23rd, 2009 by · No Comments · classroom formative assessment

This, to me, is one of the more exciting things I’ve done here in 27J because it brings together a community of people in a very collaborative, digital environment that enhances the learning experience!  For those of you who are just starting with this, welcome to the start of your very own PLN (Personal Learning Network).  Coupled with an RSS reader (my blog entry on RSS – could be helpful), some other blogs of interest and a quest for information and opinions, this is a great way to extend your learning beyond a workshop or classroom.  I am truly looking forward to reading your thoughts, experiences and ideas!

Tags: ··

Ready, Fire, Aim!

January 22nd, 2009 by · No Comments · classroom formative assessment

Here goes an interesting experiment in communal blogging.

This blog has been created for teachers trying to implement classroom formative assessment as a regular practice, and everyone who has been trained in some aspect of assessment for learning can post on this site using their 27J email address.

Ian Jones and I are administrators on this site, so please email one of us if you have questions or comments.

Tags: