As I find myself making fabulous mistakes and improving my teaching, finding more and more effective ways to help my students become better learners I am struck by this notion of; How “good” is good enough. I have reached the summit with selecting targets and clarifying them for my students. I feel confident in my rubrics and exemplars and other tools that help my students define proficient for their work and for their understanding….or do I? The discussions regarding the 90-90-90 schools keeps me thinking, would any teacher be able to walk into my room…use the tools I’ve supplied my students as a guide for grades and grade my kids the same way I would? Well, I’ve put it to the first of what I imagine will be many tests.
I used the opportunity created by attending this group to enlist a sub to help me test just this. In my sub plans I asked my sub (who, by the way, was the fabulous and amazing retired Kindergarten teacher Mrs. Judi Martinez…so we all know she knows her “stuff”. ) to use my exemplars as tools and grade an assignment that she gave the students while I was away. I did not ask her to take into account anyone’s ELL status, nothing about the higher or lower ability levels in the room. She was to use the descriptors and exemplars of proficient work to grade my students on their performance.
I must say I was very pleasantly surprised that in all but one case the sub and I agreed completely on what proficient looked like and because it was based on more than a subjective feeling of “good” work and because it was clearly outlined inside my classroom this was possible.
I then took it one step farther….I conferences with my students individually and asked them why they think they received the mark they did on that assignment. Again success! Most (yes there were about 4 of 42 that cocked their 5 year old heads to one side and gave me a blank look. ) could verbalize exactly what proficient was to look like and how their work contained those qualities.
So now I come to the point of my post…..finally!
I would like to extend and continue this little experiment and I ask for your help. I’m looking for some ambitious soul to grade some of my students works based on the tools we use in the classroom to describe proficient and in return I’ll happily do the same. Let’s work together. The commitment involved to grade my assignment is about an hour.
Any takers?
Beginning after conferences is absolutely the plan.
Angelina Harskjold
Thimmig Kindergarten
aharskjold@sd27j.org
